More than 200 book lovers and concerned residents are up
in arms about the proposed closing of at least five Oakland
branch libraries and other cuts in library services. They
gathered at the Lakeview Branch of the Oakland Public
Library last weekend to plan their counter attack.
As part of the Oakland's need to slash millions from its
current fiscal year budget, the libraries have been asked to
cut $2 million from, or about 40 percent of, what's left of
the general fund. That fund stands at about $4.8 million.
"This is a
disproportionately large cut compared to other
departments," said Oakland City Councilwoman Jean Quan,
District 4 (Montclair-Laurel).
"We have already frozen all expenditures relating to
books and equipment," said Carmen Martinez, the city's
library director. "There is nothing else left to
cut."
Seventy percent of the library department's spending is
used to pay salaries, so any cuts will be hard felt by the
community, residents said.
Martinez and her staff came up with several scenarios and
plan to submit their final suggestions on the proposed
budget cuts to the Oakland City Council before Feb. 7.
The library's latest plan, known as Plan Three, provides
for seven "regional branches" -- a new category or
designation for libraries that will remain open with their
current hours: West Oakland, Rockridge, Asian, Brookfield,
Cesar Chavez, Eastmont and Dimond. The five branches slated
for closing under this plan are: Lakeview, Martin Luther
King Jr., Melrose, Elmhurst and Piedmont Avenue. The Golden
Gate, Montclair and Temescal branches are set to stay open
three days a week, down from their current five.
Plan Three aims to reduce the library budget by $1.7
million.
"This was my charge, not my heart," said
Martinez, who lobbied and received funding last year to
extend library hours. (Those funds have since disappeared.)
Amy Pierce of state Assemblyman Don Perata's office,
pointed to the potential repeal of the vehicle license fees,
which the state shares with the city. "The (fees are)
the lifeblood for local financing. Without it, there is very
little local communities can do to raise money."
It is expected that Gov. Gray Davis will fight to keep
these fees, rather than pass them back to cities and other
areas where they are collected, as the state has done in the
past.
Pierce suggested that residents contact the governor and
ask that the vehicle license fees be shared with communities
like Oakland. "This is a very contentious issue. Please
write to the governor. "Future cuts will not end with
the libraries," Pierce warned.
Frank Brodsky, a member of Friends of the Lakeview
Library and a facilitator of Saturday's meeting, called for
all branches to remain open at their current hours. It would
only be detrimental for individual groups to begin lobbying
specifically for the branch in their neighborhood, he
cautioned.
"We want a coordinated effort, so we are not
repeating ourselves," Brodesky stressed.
"It is interesting that the libraries are expected
to make what seems to be a disproportionate cut in their
budgets, however, to be realistic, we should expect some
cuts," conceded Rita Liberti, a resident of the Rose
Garden district.
But many residents remained vehemently opposed to any
cuts in library services.
"The libraries are one of the most important
services" said Terry Gross, a resident of Crocker
Highlands. "(They are) something that provides access
for minimum and low-income citizens. These things should be
the last cut -- not first."
"This always happens. We are the last to be heard,
said Asline Jones, a property owner in both East and West
Oakland and former librarian. "(Residents of East and
West Oakland) don't have computers or cars. They have to
take, already bad, public transportation to get to another
branch to use these services."
Residents in more affluent areas of the city have cars
and therefore can more easily drive to a branch in another
neighborhood, Jones explained. "I am (angry), because
we are always overlooked."
Jones received an enormous round of applause from the
audience.
Those at the meeting then worked on what they should do
before the City Council votes on the proposed cuts at its
special 10 a.m. Friday, Feb. 7 meeting. Many exuberant
supporters signed up for letter writing, fiscal analysis,
Web support and other tasks.
"We need to blanket the city and newspapers with
letters," Brodesky said.
Many residents at the meeting were ready to act.
"The people of Oakland are being robbed of their
past and future," said Miron Mursury, an artist and
Grand Lake resident. "The closing of the libraries are
endemic to the loss of society. When they are gone, they
will never come back."
"This is an
amazing outpouring. Keep it up," Quan said. "We
need to develop a long-term strategy. People are not seeing
that right now. They are reacting to a mid-year crisis. The
city is looking at more cuts in June. We must be
smarter."
To join the effort to save the libraries, send e-mail
messages to save__Oakland_libraries@hotmail.com.
To sign or obtain a petition, call 510-444-4984 or send
e-mail to Maggie_Kostoff@hotmail.com.
To contact the governor about vehicle license fees, see www.governor.ca.gov,
or mail letters to Gov. Gray Davis, State Capital,
Sacramento, CA 95814.